DPPA forum shows workings of city commissions By Andrew Slade, DPPA board member
DPPA hosted the forum "Duluth Commissions: Bridging Citizens
and Government" last June 3. A great turnout of 40 people
and five panel members filled the Duluth Public Library's Green
Room with experiences, ideas and reflections on how city
commissions engage citizens in the governance of Duluth.
The panel members were all supportive of the commission
process. They reflected on the long hours and the occasional
public pressures and mis-perceptions. Looking back on the forum,
the following points seem to emerge:
Help wanted
City commissions work because their members work. DPPA
distributed applications for open commission seats and
encouraged folks to sign up. The city doesn't necessarily come
to you to invite you in. Panel members said they gave between
four and twenty hours a week to their volunteer commission work.
Advice needed
Though most of the commissions are purely advisory in their
relation with the city, that advice is generally heeded. As
panelist Frank Jewell from the housing commission explained, if
the commission votes against a proposal, it is likely to get a
poor reception in the city administration.
Politics as usual?
One unresolved topic was the extent to which the city's strong
mayor system allows the mayor to "stack" commissions.
Applications are screened and evaluated by an advisory
committee to the mayor. The mayor makes appointments, which are
then reviewed and approved by the city council. Some people
feel left out of this process, contending their applications to
serve were never accepted. Most panel members felt that the
process was fair and open, only getting political in the case
of the Planning Commission.
Thanks to all the panelists and to the audience for a great
forum. And thanks again to AFSCME for its sponsorship.
Panelists from left to right, C.J. Bird, Carol Thomson,
Frank Jewell, Meg Bye, Eric Kaiser.
Panelists:
C.J. Bird, American Indian Commission
Meg Bye, Human Rights Commission
Frank Jewell, Housing Commission
Eric Kaiser, Spirit Mountain Authority
Carol Thomson, Planning Commission
These articles are retained on
the web for historical interest and do not necessarily reflect the
views or goals of DPPA today.
|